The Lethal Contest Mistakes Most Brands Make (And How to Win)

Quick Answer

3-Step Contest Framework:

1. Prize Alignment - Match prize to target audience (not just biggest prize)
2. Simple Entry - One clear action beats complex rules
3. Platform Rules - Follow each platform's guidelines or get banned

Success metrics: Significant follower growth, higher engagement rates, email conversions.

To run successful contests, use the right social media scheduling tools to manage entries and maintain momentum.

Critical mistake: Choosing a prize everyone wants (iPad, cash) instead of what your ideal customer wants. This attracts freebie hunters, not real customers.

---

Why Most Contests Fail

Failed Contests:

• Generic prizes (iPhone, cash)
• Complex multi-step entries
• No follow-up after contest
• Ignoring platform rules

Successful Contests:

• Product-specific prizes
• Single clear action
• Winner announcement + follow-up plan
• Platform-compliant mechanics

---

Fatal Mistakes to Avoid

1. Wrong Prize Selection

What brands do wrong: "Let's give away an iPhone to get max entries!"

Result: 10,000 entries from people who want iPhones, not your product.

The fix: Give away YOUR product or service. A photography course company should offer a free course, not a camera.

2. Platform Rule Violations

Instagram violations:

• Requiring "tag everyone you know"
• "Share to story for extra entries"
• Requiring shares for entry

Safe contest mechanics:

Instagram:

• Like this post ✓
• Follow account ✓
• Tag friend in comments ✓
• Share to story ✗

Facebook:

• Like Page ✓
• Comment on post ✓
• Personal timeline shares ✗

TikTok:

• Use specific hashtag ✓
• Create duet/stitch ✓
• Follow account ✓

Twitter/X:

• Retweet with comment ✓
• Follow + Like + RT ✓
• Use branded hashtag ✓

3. Complicated Entry Requirements

Bad Example: "To enter: Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, share to story, tag 5 friends, subscribe to newsletter, visit website..."

Good Example: "To enter: 1. Follow @yourbrand 2. Tag 2 friends"

Entry Optimization:

• 1 action: highest completion
• 2 actions: moderate completion
• 3+ actions: very low completion

4. No Clear Rules

Must include in official rules:

• Contest start/end dates + timezone
• How to enter (exact steps)
• Eligibility (age, location)
• Prize description and value
• Winner selection method
• "No purchase necessary"
• Platform disclaimer

---

Step-by-Step Contest Guide

Phase 1: Strategy

1. Define Clear Goal

• Follower growth? Set target: "Gain 1,000 followers"
• Engagement? Benchmark: "300% increase in comments"
• Email list? Goal: "500 new subscribers"

2. Choose Prize Strategically

Prize ideas by business:

• E-commerce: Product bundle, store gift card
• Service: Free month of service, VIP upgrade
• B2B: Annual subscription, training package
• Creator: Exclusive content, collaboration

3. Create Official Rules Page Host complete rules on your website. Include in every post: "Full rules: [yourwebsite.com/contest-rules]"

Phase 2: Launch

Announcement Post Formula:

🎉 GIVEAWAY TIME! 🎉

We're giving away [Prize]!

HOW TO ENTER:
1️⃣ Follow @yourbrand
2️⃣ Tag 2 friends in comments

Winner announced [Date]!
Full rules: [link]

Cross-promote:

• Email list
• All social channels
• Stories with countdown
• Website banner

Phase 3: Momentum

Daily actions:

• Respond to ALL comments
• Share to stories with countdown
• Thank participants
• Post UGC from entries

Mid-contest boosts:

• Day 5: "Halfway there!"
• Day 10: "48 hours left!"
• Behind-the-scenes content

Phase 4: Winner Selection

Selection methods:

• Random draw: Use Comment Picker, Gleam, Woobox
• Judged: Set clear criteria beforehand

Winner announcement:

1. Notify winner privately first (48-hour deadline)
2. Public announcement after confirmation
3. Deliver prize promptly

Phase 5: Post-Contest

Convert contest traffic:

• Offer discount code for non-winners
• Send welcome sequence to new followers
• Analyze performance metrics
• Maintain momentum with consistent posting

---

Contest Duration

Ideal length: 7-14 days

• Under 7 days: Not enough reach
• Over 14 days: People lose interest

---

Platform-Specific Ideas

Instagram

Tag-a-Friend Contest:

• Entry: Tag 2 friends
• Duration: 7 days
• Expected reach: 5-10x follower count

Photo Challenge:

• Entry: Post with #BrandChallenge
• Duration: 14 days
• Result: 50-200 UGC posts

Facebook

Comment to Win:

• Entry: Best comment wins
• Duration: 5 days
• Engagement: 3-7x normal

Poll Contest:

• Entry: Vote + comment why
• Duration: 3 days
• Bonus: Audience insights

TikTok

Hashtag Challenge:

• Entry: Video with #BrandChallenge
• Duration: 7-14 days
• Viral potential: Very high

Duet Contest:

• Entry: Create duet + tag
• Duration: 10 days
• High sharing

Twitter/X

Retweet to Win:

• Entry: RT + Follow
• Duration: 24-72 hours
• High viral potential

Reply Challenge:

• Entry: Best reply wins
• Duration: 2-3 days
• Quality engagement

---

Legal Considerations

Required disclaimers: "This promotion is in no way sponsored, endorsed or administered by [Platform]. By entering, entrants confirm 18+, release [Platform] of responsibility, and agree to official rules: [link]"

Age restrictions: Require 18+ to avoid parental consent issues

Prize value:

• Under $600: No tax reporting (US)
• Over $600: Winner provides W-9

Geographic restrictions:

• State clearly: "Open to [Country] residents only"
• Include "Void where prohibited"

---

FAQ

How long should a social media contest run?

The ideal contest duration is 7-14 days. Shorter doesn't allow enough organic reach, while longer causes people to lose interest.

What makes a good contest prize?

The best prizes are your own products or services, not generic items. This attracts qualified leads who actually want what you offer, not just freebie hunters.

Can I require people to share my post to enter?

No. Instagram and Facebook prohibit requiring shares as contest entry. You can ask to tag friends, follow, or comment only.

How do I pick a contest winner fairly?

Use a random selection tool like Comment Picker, Gleam, or Woobox. For judged contests, establish clear criteria beforehand.

How often should I run contests?

Monthly or quarterly contests work best. Too frequent makes them less special, too infrequent misses growth opportunities.

---

Related: Social Media Content Calendar · Campaign URL Builder · Instagram Hashtag Tool